More phones we considered
6. Google Pixel 9a: Not ideal
The Google Pixel 9a gets a lot of attention thanks to its high quality camera, AI tools, and relatively low price (about $400 to $500). And Google Family Link, the company's free parental control app, is (of course) compatible with the phone.
However, we don't think Google Family Link is thorough enough for most families because it doesn't offer text monitoring or location history. There are also several workarounds that allow kids to remove the controls, and recent reviews mention frustrating glitches.
Downloading (and paying for) a different parental control app can give you more comprehensive digital protection on the Pixel 9a. However, third-party apps can often be bypassed. Phones designed with integrated parental controls, like the Bark Phone or Gabb Phone, are impossible to defeat and remain our top choice for keeping kids safe in a digital world.
If you want to support an older teen as they learn how to safely navigate the internet, the Google Pixel 9a and Google Family Link might fit your needs. But for younger kids who aren't ready for the internet or unmonitored messaging, it's a no-go.
It's the same with other Android phones
You can download Google Family Link on any Android device, like the Samsung Galaxy, but the issues remain the same.
The Samsung Kids app is more for temporarily turning your phone into a safe playground for younger kids (ages 3 to 8) than for giving kids their very own phone.
7. Apple iPhone: Not ideal
Like Google, Apple designed a free parental control app that works with its line of smartphones. Unfortunately, Apple's "Screen Time" app is no more effective than Google Family Link.
For example, web blocking is remarkably inefficient. Parents can block adult websites or manually create a list of sites they don't want their child to visit. There's no in between. Other parental control apps let parents choose from dozens of content categories to block or filter.
So, the best thing to do is add a third-party parental control app. And, as we mentioned with the Google Pixel, these are susceptible to workarounds. Many also have extremely limited features due to Apple's rules about permissions, tracking, and privacy.
We know it's tempting to give your child your old iPhone as a hand-me-down, but your child is more likely to be exposed to the ugly side of the internet on an iPhone than on a phone specially designed for their age, needs, and innocence.
Consider an iPhone as a gift for your child's 18th birthday. Until then, proceed with caution.
8. Tin Can Phone: Retro option
With the Tin Can phone, you can give your child a "landline" phone (it's really powered by Wi-Fi or an Ethernet cable) and allow them to only call certain numbers.
It gives them all the fun of chatting with grandma and grandpa, their cousins, and their friends without any concerns about screen time, prank calls, or scams. You can also set quiet times so your kid doesn't stay up all night talking!
It's a super cute option for kids to use at home or on vacation, but it's not suitable for kids who need a phone when they're away from family.
9. Palm Phone: Pocket-friendly option
The Palm Phone is a tiny smartphone with powerful features. Just like an iPhone or Android phone, the Palm has apps, social media, and internet-browsing capabilities.
You'll need to pair the Palm Phone with a parental control app to protect your child, but it's one of the few options they'll be able to fit in their pockets or hands.
Learn more in our full Palm Phone review.
10. Wisephone: Ultra-minimalist design
The Wisephone caters to adults who need to cut down on their screen time. It calls, texts, takes pictures, and includes only the bare-minimum apps necessary for modern life: maps, a clock, and a calculator.
There's also a family portal that lets parents monitor their child's call history, texts, and location. But we hesitate to recommend the Wisephone as a kids phone. Kids need guidance, and the Wisephone simply restricts all access.
11. Lightphone: Basically an iPod that calls and texts
We also considered the Lightphone for our lineup of kids phones. Like the Wisephone, the Lightphone is mainly for adults to avoid endless scrolling. There are no parent-friendly features, so your child could end up texting and calling anyone and everyone.
But that's the only real mischief they could get into. It does play music and podcasts, so it's not totally boring. But there's no internet, games, or camera on board.
But for $300 upfront and at least $30/month, you don't get much bang for your buck.
12. Teracube Thrive: App management and little else
Teracube's claim to fame is its environmentally-friendly smartphone. We tested the Teracube Thrive — which is just the normal Teracube 2e paired with Teracube's parental control app — and weren't impressed.
It has excellent app management, but the SPIN browser did nothing to curb our mature searches. Worse yet, none of our web activity showed up on the parental dashboard. There was a frustrating lack of customization options or reports.
At this point, the Teracube Thrive is just getting a participation trophy. Steer clear.
13. VTech KiddiBuzz 3: Best for preschoolers
The VTech KidiBuzz 3 isn't really a cell phone, but your youngster won't know the difference. Designed for kids age 4 and up, the VTech KidiBuzz 3 has a touchscreen, camera, educational and just-for-fun games, and a secure messaging app that works over Wi-Fi.
The VTech KidiBuzz 3 doesn't make phone calls or track your child's location, but it gives your kid a smartphone-like device to use just like their older siblings. Because it doesn't connect to a cellular network, you don't have to worry about paying a monthly fee.
You can set daily screen time limits and download music or videos to the device if you need to keep your kid extra entertained. There's even a headphone jack to give you some peace.