Top 10 Metro Areas Where Porch Pirates Strike Most

Written by | Updated November 16, 2018

Having a package swiped from your stoop puts a real damper on your holiday spirit. Porch pirates are out in full force during the holidays—walking away with goodies from nearly 26 million Americans.¹

Black Friday and Cyber Monday have already made their 2018 debuts, but there’s little doubt that package thieves are still skulking in the wings. Last year the big three package delivery services (UPS, FedEx, and USPS) were as busy as Santa, delivering an estimated two billion bundles between Thanksgiving and New Year’s.² That’s a lot of booty for a porch pirate to go after—but where you live can make a difference.

With the busiest shipping season of the year in full swing, SafeWise decided to find out where these dastardly desperadoes strike most. Find out if you live in dangerous waters or see if your hometown is a safe harbor.

SafeWise Porch Theft Metro Areas Infographic

A Closer Look at the Findings

SafeWise looked at larceny-theft rates and Google Trends data to identify the most and least risky places for package theft. We compared year-round data with incidents during the holiday season to identify the best and worst metro areas for porch piracy.

  • Half of the top package theft metros also land in the top 10 for larceny-theft overall—Salt Lake City (1), Seattle-Tacoma (3), Miami-Fort Lauderdale (4), Raleigh-Durham (6), and Atlanta (7).
  • Texas has the most incidence of high holiday package theft, with three metro areas making our list: Austin, Houston, and Dallas-Fort Worth.
  • Half the metros on our list are from Texas and Florida—Texas has three and Florida has two.
  • Only three of the top 10 metro areas that are most likely to have stolen packages also make the top 10 for porch theft during the rest of the year—Austin, Salt Lake City, and Seattle-Tacoma.
  • Miami-Fort Lauderdale scores zero for stolen package searches year-round, but jumps to 31 (out of 100) during the holidays, making it the third most likely place to get your holiday packages pilfered!
  • Surprisingly, New York City is the least likely place to have a package swiped during the holidays.
  • The national metro theft rate is almost 17 incidents per 1,000 people, and three of our most risky metros stayed under that—Dallas-Fort Worth, Tampa-St. Petersburg, and Boston.

Overall Theft Rates for the Metros with the Most Holiday Package Theft

Holiday Theft Rank Metro Area State Year-Round Theft Rate* 
1 Austin Texas 18.43
2 Salt Lake City Utah 32.60
3 Miami-Fort Lauderdale Florida 23.62
4 Atlanta Georgia 20.80
5 Raleigh-Durham North Carolina 21.85
6 Seattle-Tacoma Washington 24.44
7 Houston Texas 19.29
8 Dallas-Fort Worth Texas 16.70
9 Tampa-St. Petersburg Florida 15.94
10 Boston Massachusetts 11.97

*Per 1,000 people

How to Prevent Porch Theft

Here are some tools and best practices to protect your Black Friday purchases and make those porch pirates walk the plank:

  • Use package delivery tracking
  • Add insurance and require a signature for delivery
  • Use a package locker (Amazon Lockers, PO Box)
  • Install security cameras or a doorbell camera
  • Send your goodies to the office or pick them up in person (UPS, FedEx)

What to Do If a Package Is Stolen

Precautions are a must, but sometimes packages get purloined anyway. If you’re a victim of package theft, here are some things you can do to minimize the damage:

  • Contact the carrier and the retailer
  • File a report with insurance, police, the carrier, etc.
  • Alert your credit card company
  • Check your video footage
  • Check your neighbor’s video footage

Yo Ho, Yo Ho, Some Final Thoughts before You Go

Don’t get raided by porch pirates this holiday season. Whether you’re shopping online or shipping goodies to friends and family, use these tips and resources to ensure safe passage for your packages—especially if you live in a high-risk area.


To see where porch pirates run rampant, SafeWise analyzed 2017 FBI larceny data in metro areas across the US and compared it to Google Trends data in those areas with the highest search for “missing package” and “stolen package.” We then compared average search interest over the past 12 months to search interest during the holiday season (November 19–January 6) to find the metro areas that are most vulnerable to package theft during the holidays.³  

Written by Rebecca Edwards

Rebecca has honed her safety and security skills as both a single mom and a college director. Being responsible for the well-being of others helped her learn how to minimize risk and create safe environments. Learn more

Share this article.
  • Michael Christopher Scott

    I’ve never had a problem with porch-pirates. My townhouse complex has only one way in and one way out. There is thus no through-traffic, so no opportunity theft. During 22 years year, I have only encountered one vagrant. He was asleep on my patio, so I awakened him with a boot to his head.

    When he exclaimed “What’s your problem?” I politely explained that I have a gun, not a problem. Since he didn’t want any .41″ Action Express, he wisely ran away. There are no vagrants in the neighborhood now. I suspect the word got out.

    I work from home making fishing lures, so I am home most times. Absolutely nobody comes here without my noticing.

    “Do Not Notice This Notice. Your Noticing It Has Been Noticed, And Will Be Noted.”.

    Below that, it says “The CIA Is Watching The FBI Watch Me While I Watch You.”

    • newscomments70

      Why did you stop commenting? Sorry if that is too personal of a question.

      • Norman

        I loved it too much, and was banned when I slipped up and said the dreaded n-word. Rats!

        It doesn’t matter anymore. I read about the Knoxville Horror on AmRen, and wish I had not. Don’t read about it. I wish there were things I could unread, and that’s at the top of the list. It’s heartbreaking. It’ll hurt you in a place you can’t reach.

        My mother grew up on cowboy movies, so she likes those. She can’t stand war movies, or the violent horror science-fiction movies I prefer. In the 1979 movie “Alien”, the chest-burst scene was filmed without most of the cast members knowing what was going to happen. This shocked them. That was the whole point.

        I can’t watch murder investigation TV shows. With monsters from outer space, at least I know that’s fake, but I don’t want to see something about someone getting murdered. It’s just so sad.

        • newscomments70

          Thanks for your response. I understand your sentiments. I try to avoid the news, even “conservative” news. It simply makes me angry all of the time. I like old movies and TV as well. It’s comforting to revisit better times. I can’t do much to stop what is happening in the real world, and there’s no point in being angry all of the time. Back to you being banned, it’s funny how the folks who complain about “deplatforming” are guilty of the same activity.

  • Michael Christopher Scott

    I was banned from AmRen. They gripe about totalitarianism and censorship, but they do the same thing, themselves. That’s hypocritical. They could have edited my comment or deleted it, or put me on some sort of probation, but they didn’t.

    They got over ten years of writing out of me, for free. Now I write product reviews for Amazon.

    • De Deplorable Doc

      Hey! I wondered what happened to you. It’s sad that you were banned from AmRen – many have missed your humor and commentary. I was zapped from Breitbart recently for referring to Ilan Omar as a ‘POS’. The cowardly Cuckservatives strike again. Anyway I hope all is well and do take care.

      • Norman

        I sometimes post there as Norman from another account. That’s my maternal grandfather’s name. I try to keep things a little subdued, even though he died almost 30 years ago.

      • Norman

        Omar is in fact a POS, as is AOC. I’m glad we have them in office, however, as they are probably red-pilling more fence sitters with every word they utter. “Some people did some things.” In fact some “people” wantonly murdered about 3000 innocent Americans.

        God only knows how many of the short-term survivors will die from inhaling the dust from asbestos insulation. The WTC was built when asbestos was commonly used in construction. That poor black woman, covered with dust in the famous photo, a.k.a “dust lady” has since died. Doubtless there are many others. I don’t like blacks, but I don’t want them poisoned just because they were at work somewhere. That’s horrible.

      • Katherine McChesney

        I was banned from Breitbart a few years ago for tell the truth about black criminality.

    • Katherine McChesney

      They banned me a few years ago for posting the trust against the Jew haters and the satanic Jesuits. American Renaissance is NOT a true conservative site.

      • Norman

        They banned the Romanian fellow who went by “Spartacus” because he openly advocated violence. I’m 53, have a family and live in a quiet suburb of Colorado Springs. I don’t want violence, except as a last resort.

        I had continuously posted to AmRen openly advocating common sense, which isn’t all that common. That’s why insurance rates are so high. I did that for 14 years, for free. Given the choice between violence and being some middle-aged crackpot who makes fishing tackle at home, I’ll pick the latter, eight days a week.

        Perhaps AmRen is worried about lawsuits. I can’t possibly know.

        The worst thing I recently did was suggest yet more of the local landscaping crew buy cheap foam ear protection plugs at a sporting goods store, the kind shooters use. Those gasoline-powered blowers are very loud. That will wreck one’s hearing over prolonged use.

        I’m big on safety, because I once worked with dangerous chemicals. The old safety glasses were dirty, and I ruined them by running them through the dishwasher. My choices from Amazon for the current, best-rated versions were either one set for $4.99 plus $5 in shipping, or a 12-pack for $12.99 with free “Prime” shipping. I ought to send two pairs to my sister and nephew.

    • Katherine McChesney

      I was banned by AmRen for telling the truth about the Roman Catholic church, it’s pedophiles, it’s paganism and the fact that it is the head of the New World Order. Jared’s moderators was a graduate of a Jesuit school and I suppose he was angry that I exposed his satanic leaders. I miss your comments Michael. Hope you are doing well.

    • dd121

      Hi Michael,
      I wondered why you weren’t on AmRen any more. Thought maybe space aliens had kidnapped you.
      I know how it feels. I don’t post much on AmRen anymore but I posted on Fox News a lot and got banned there.
      The sun will supernova in 5 billion years.