SimpliSafe vs. Blue by ADT

We researched and tried both SimpliSafe and Blue by ADT and found SimpliSafe had more security options.
Winner
SimpliSafe
SimpliSafe
4.5 out of 5 stars
4.45
Starts at
$14.99
/mo
  • Icon Pros  Light
    Low monthly cost
  • Icon Pros  Light
    Professional installation and easy DIY installation
  • Icon Cons  Light
    Basic cameras
Runner up
Blue by ADT
Blue by ADT
4 out of 5 stars
4
Starts at
$19.99
  • Icon Pros  Light
    Low monthly cost
  • Icon Pros  Light
    Easy DIY installation
  • Icon Cons  Light
    Expensive cameras

When you compare Blue by ADT vs. SimpliSafe, SimpliSafe takes the prize. While we found both home security systems easy to use and affordable, SimpliSafe offered, well, more. It features a bevy of helpful security equipment options, the versatility of pro or DIY installation, and a better return policy than Blue.

Here’s how everything shook out after we tested and compared these two systems.


SimpliSafe vs. Blue by ADT at a glance


SimpliSafe Pros and Cons

Pro Heading
Pros
Pro Bullet No contract required
Pro Bullet Low monthly cost
Pro Bullet Large device selection
Pro Bullet Affordable equipment
Pro Bullet 60-day money-back guarantee
Con Heading
Cons
Con Bullet Not compatible with Z-Wave
Con Bullet Basic cameras

SimpliSafe is best for people who want great connectivity

If you need a bunch of devices that all work well together, SimpliSafe is a good choice. It has a device for just about everything. From smoke detection to intruder detection, SimpliSafe has you covered.

And its security cameras are affordable, so you can get multiple cameras for your home. This can be particularly helpful if you have a large yard or home that needs a bunch of cameras for full coverage.

Blue by ADT Pros and Cons

Pro Heading
Pros
Pro Bullet No contract required
Pro Bullet Low monthly cost
Pro Bullet Compatible with Z-Wave
Pro Bullet Highly trusted company
Pro Bullet 60-day money-back guarantee
Con Heading
Cons
Con Bullet Expensive cameras
Con Bullet No professional installation

Blue by ADT is best for those that need a trusted name

Blue by ADT is for people who want a little extra reassurance that everything is going to work. It’s a highly trusted company with decades of experience. ADT has been around for more than 140 years. Though the Blue version of ADT has only been around a few years, it’s still backed by ADT and its nine monitoring centers. These centers have generators and redundancy plans to ensure its customers never go without service.

Plus, Blue by ADT has a lower entry price, making it easier to get started if you’re on a budget.

Lowest monitoring price
Mobile app included w/ base plan
Smart home compatibility
Equipment options
Learn more
SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe

Icon No  LightNo
Alexa, Google, August Smart Lock
Blue by ADT

Blue by ADT

Icon Yes  LightYes
Alexa, Google, IFTTT, Z-Wave

Info current as of 06/21/21. Offers and availability may vary by location and are subject to change.

Similarities

We love that both of these companies seem to look out for the customer. Both have no contract and offer inexpensive packages and monitoring.

No contract

Unlike some other big names in the industry (we’re looking at you ADT), neither SimpliSafe nor Blue make you sign a contract. While this means that you need to pay for your equipment up front, you won’t be locked into an agreement or pay a penalty if you decide to try a different security system company.

Base kit price
Highest kit price
Build your own
Number of kits
Base kit includes
Learn more
SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe

5Base station, Keypad, Entry sensor, Motion sensor
Blue by ADT

Blue by ADT

3Hub with built-in keypad, Door/window sensors (2), Yard sign, Window stickers

Info current as of 06/21/21. Offers and availability may vary by location and are subject to change.

Cost

There isn’t much difference in price. Blue by ADT is slightly cheaper, but SimpliSafe offers more packages to choose from.

SimpliSafe has five home security system packages that range from $229 to $489. You can DIY yourself a customized package too. Customized packages start at $184.

Blue by ADT has three packages that range from $179.99 to $449.97. Custom packages start at $179.99.

Differences

While Blue has more pricey professional monitoring, it has the edge overall. SimpliSafe provides the knockout in the equipment, installation, and return policy categories, though.

Professional monitoring

Both SimpliSafe and Blue offer low monthly monitoring-plan fees. What you get for the price is where the brands differ. Let’s take a look at SimpliSafe’s most affordable package and Blue by ADT’s only package. As you can see, you get what you pay for.

Cost
Mobile app access
Video storage
Smart home integration
Learn more
SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe

Icon No  LightNo
Icon No  LightNo
Icon No  LightNo
Blue by ADT

Blue by ADT

Icon Yes  LightYes
Icon Yes  LightYes
Icon Yes  LightYes

Info current as of 06/21/21. Offers and availability may vary by location and are subject to change.

To get all of the features that the Blue by ADT plan offers, you’ll need to upgrade to SimpliSafe’s Interactive Plan for $24.99 per month. Since the premium package is only a few dollars more, SimpliSafe and Blue by ADT are on even footing. We just want to make sure you don’t get fooled into thinking SimpliSafe is a bargain by looking at its lowest monthly package rate.

Both also allow you to go without a monitoring package, which we don’t recommend. Without monitoring, you lose too many features that make a security system useful.

You can learn more in our SimpliSafe monitoring packages guide.

Equipment

When it comes to equipment, SimpliSafe is the clear winner. SimpliSafe security systems offer you more ways to keep your home safe by offering a wider range of devices. Blue doesn’t have glass-break sensors, carbon monoxide detectors, smoke detectors, panic buttons, or key fobs. Blue doesn’t have a smart lock either.

SimpliSafe equipment

  • Base station
  • Keypad
  • Entry sensor
  • Motion sensor
  • Water sensor
  • Glass-break sensor
  • Panic button
  • Smoke detector
  • Carbon monoxide sensor
  • Temperature sensor
  • SimpliCam
  • Key fob
  • Extra siren
  • Video doorbell
  • Smartlock

Learn more about SimpliSafe’s equipment and compatibility here.

Blue by ADT equipment

  • Blue by ADT Smart Home Hub
  • Keypad
  • Window sensor
  • Door sensor
  • Motion sensor
  • Flood and temperature sensor
  • Doorbell camera
  • Indoor camera
  • Outdoor camera
  • Google Nest Mini
  • Extender and chime
  • Wireless outdoor camera extra battery pack

Learn more about Blue by ADT’s equipment and compatibility here.

Cameras

The biggest equipment comparison is between cameras. Blue has the edge when it comes to security camera surveillance, but not by much.

SimpliSafe has two cameras: the SimpliCam and the Doorbell Pro. SimpliCam is an indoor camera. You may notice there isn’t an outdoor option for SimpliSafe. You can get a cover that works as a raincoat for SimpliCam to make it an outdoor camera. We guess that counts as having an outdoor camera in your lineup, but it means extra steps, and we hate that.

Blue by ADT has three security camera options, including an outdoor camera, an indoor camera, and a doorbell camera. Right off the bat, Blue by ADT cameras have more coverage than SimpliSafe if you don’t want to buy rain protection for your indoor camera.

Blue’s cameras are better quality too. Each offers 1080p video quality, which is the industry standard. While the SimpliSafe Doorbell Pro has 1080p, SimpliCam comes in at just 720p. Blue’s cameras have more features, as well, including two-way talk and a slightly wider field of view.

Okay, so we’ve really talked up the Blue cameras, but they have one big problem. The price. Both Blue indoor and outdoor cameras cost $199.99, while the SimpliCam comes in at just $99. Blue’s indoor camera is twice as expensive as SimpliCam. And even if you add the $20 raincoat to SimpliCam to make it an outdoor camera, it’s still way cheaper than Blue’s outdoor camera.

So how do the doorbell cameras stack up? They’re a little closer in price. The SimpliSafe Doorbell Pro is $169 and the Blue Doorbell Camera is $199.99. The features are similar too. Both have 1080p video, a wide field of view, two-way talk, and motion detection.

Installation

The biggest equipment comparison is between cameras. Blue has the edge when it comes to security camera surveillance, but not by much.

SimpliSafe has two cameras: the SimpliCam and the Doorbell Pro. SimpliCam is an indoor camera. You may notice there isn’t an outdoor option for SimpliSafe. You can get a cover that works as a raincoat for SimpliCam to make it an outdoor camera. We guess that counts as having an outdoor camera in your lineup, but it means extra steps, and we hate that.

Blue by ADT has three security camera options, including an outdoor camera, an indoor camera, and a doorbell camera. Right off the bat, Blue by ADT cameras have more coverage than SimpliSafe if you don’t want to buy rain protection for your indoor camera.

Blue’s cameras are better quality too. Each offers 1080p video quality, which is the industry standard. While the SimpliSafe Doorbell Pro has 1080p, SimpliCam comes in at just 720p. Blue’s cameras have more features, as well, including two-way talk and a slightly wider field of view.

Okay, so we’ve really talked up the Blue cameras, but they have one big problem. The price. Both Blue indoor and outdoor cameras cost $199.99, while the SimpliCam comes in at just $99. Blue’s indoor camera is twice as expensive as SimpliCam. And even if you add the $20 raincoat to SimpliCam to make it an outdoor camera, it’s still way cheaper than Blue’s outdoor camera.

So how do the doorbell cameras stack up? They’re a little closer in price. The SimpliSafe Doorbell Pro is $169 and the Blue Doorbell Camera is $199.99. The features are similar too. Both have 1080p video, a wide field of view, two-way talk, and motion detection.

Money-back guarantee

What happens if you choose your new home security system and find out you don’t like it? Well, both of these systems give you a window to return your equipment and get your money back.

Blue by ADT gives you just 30 days to get your money back on equipment and services. SimpliSafe gives you a 60-day window, which can give you more time to settle in, work out any bugs, and really get a feel for the equipment.

Winner: SimpliSafe beats Blue by ADT

While SimpliSafe and Blue by ADT are both great security systems, we have to give this one to SimpliSafe. It offers more ways to protect your home with a wide range of devices. Plus, you have the option to choose DIY or professional installation and have more days to return equipment. We love options.

SimpliSafe:

  • DIY or professional installation
  • Wider selection of security equipment
  • More affordable cameras
  • Better return policy

Blue by ADT:

  • Better cameras
  • One full-featured monitoring package
  • Lower base price

Still undecided? Read our full SimpliSafe and Blue by ADT reviews to learn more. Also, take a look at all our top security system picks.

How we decided: Blue by ADT vs. SimpliSafe

When choosing the best home security system in our SimpliSafe vs. Blue by ADT review, we did hundreds of hours of research and hands-on testing. We combined that with decades of safety and security experience.

To learn more about how Safewise reviews products and services, check out our  methodology page.

Alina Bradford
Written by
Alina Bradford
Alina has been reviewing the latest tech for more than a decade and has contributed her insights to CNET, CBS, Digital Trends, MTV, Top Ten Reviews, and many others. She specializes in smart home and security technology, working to make gadgets less mystifying one article at a time. In the early 2000s, Alina worked as a volunteer firefighter, earning her first responder certification. Her activities aren’t nearly as dangerous today. Her hobbies include fixing up her 100-year-old house, doing artsy stuff, and going to the lake with her family.

Recent Articles

Vivint App: A Complete Guide to Features and Use
Tour the Vivint app and discover its features, navigation, and customization capabilities. Learn how to...
Large craftsman style house at twilight with lights on
Best Home Security Systems of 2021
After hundreds of hours of tests and research, plus a combined 50+ years of experience,...
couple sitting on floor with moving boxes and a dog
Best Home Security Systems for Renters
These renter-friendly home security systems keep your house or apartment safe and require less commitment...
security system being installed on wall
Best DIY Home Security Systems of 2021
DIY install home security systems are cost-efficient, effective, and easy to install. See which DIY...